“When a Billion Chinese Jump” by Jonathan Watts

Author@jonathanwatts Recommended@kaiserkuo

When wrapping up this amazing book on the Environmental Crisis in CN, I was reminded of a great, but similarly gut-wrenching piece of non-fiction, Will Smith’s portrayal of Chris Gardner in the 2006 movie “The Pursuit of Happyness”. For those who haven’t seen it, it’s a dreadfully sad, but ultimately uplifting movie , about a young father trying to build a life for himself and his young son. Based on a true story, it’s amazing, scary, depressing, and yet wildly inspiring. Although it was a good movie, ultimately the experience suffered since 98% of the movie is total downer. The story Jonathan Watts takes us on, sadly, follows a similar path. You can see the arc, as Watts trucks around CN, meeting the locals, and reporting the story on the various aspects of the environment; from the dusty farmers, to the most brilliant scientists in the country, he attempts valiantly to end the book on a high note. As Watts puts it, CN is on a mission to beat the crap out of Math. How? Well, looking at the numbers, the throngs of CN people, the vastness of its land, the mountains of trash, the unimaginable statistics on pollution– it’s tempting to throw in the towel, but Watts won’t have any of it. For its part, CN is putting all its money behind the greatest scientists on Earth, and figuring out how to get cleaner water/energy, and bigger, juicier produce. The race is between a frenetic population growth and the dwindling resources that keep them all going.

On the ground in rural CN, there is a wispy paradoxical mirage, at once a driving force, and impossible to validate, and that is the dream, the delusion, that getting rich will make all the problems in the world go away. It’s one struggling lower class workers have passed around for millennia, but in 2011, at this scale, at this speed, with these stakes, the little lie that kept the Consumerist train going all these years could devastate us all.

How can you tell a farmer from HLJ province that getting rich is overrated? All they know is that life is much better now than it was 20 years ago. They have more money, and more food, than their parents did. And until their stomachs and their neighbors’ stomachs are full, the Environment will always take a backseat. And it’s not as if this is just a CN problem: the truth is, in a massively efficient global ‘organization’ of sorts, we’ve all decided (for numerous reasons) that CN is a great place to make stuff. Mass production, batch processing, cost minimization, and resource centralization, is done to perfection in South CN. So the countries from all over the world have decided to outsource not just their manufacturing industries, but the pollution that goes with it, to CN.

You see, that’s the dirty little secret. We all did this. As I sit here in my SH apartment, perhaps I should feel the most guilty. The lifestyle portrayed in SH in this book, is particularly nauseating. I actually felt physically disturbed reading about the shallow meaningless ‘social climbing’ that goes on in SH (just as it must in LA, NYC, or SF on any given night). In SH it’s the army of Nouveau Riche, and it’s what millions upon millions of empty bellied-CN here aspire to. You’ve been warned. As you read about the (now defunct) Barbie Stores, or the infamous Bar Rouge on the Bund, it’s as if city planners in the capital are saying, “take all the Foreign trash and plop it in SH… We don’t want the gaudy architecture, or all those ridiculously overpriced night clubs–and we sure aren’t going to let them put a bloody Disneyland next to the Forbidden City!! Put it all in SH.” Like the supply chain mastery and batch processing that goes on down in GD province, SH seems to be the centralized dumpsite for the wasteful foreign lifestyle. A cash cow, to be sure, but one that must be contained.

[Note: I live in SH too, and my friends don't live like those portrayed in the book. See the contradiction? Please don't take offense. It's only one aspect of the city.]

Enough needling the CN, let’s turn the question around: what would you do if you had this massive demand for Energy and Resources? Would you reach out to other countries, and set up trade missions around the word, like the recent one in Africa? Would you invest in clean technologies? Would you implement controversial and unpopular restrictions on family sizes? You’ve got all the college graduates and all the technology and all the money in the world. What would you do?

Just how far would you go to beat the Math?

7 thoughts on ““When a Billion Chinese Jump” by Jonathan Watts

  1. 我的专业就是朝鲜语(韩国语)啊。。天天都在学啊~
    在中国,山东省青岛市和天津市的韩国人算多的。青岛市个漂亮的海滨城市,去年暑假我去我那里来着~那里俄罗斯人也很多~
    中国的版图争议大部分与历史上的一些不平等条约有关。。。(我最近在学中国近代史,也是中国的屈辱史)
    前阵子有个北大的教授来做讲座,提出他对于历史的态度:积极健忘 to forget it on our initiative。他建议我们青年人放眼未来,与世界上的其他国家“求同存异”,这样才能更好地交流合作。

    • 恩, 因为中国多么广大,里面有很多不同的社会。有人说北京跟上海不一样,或者,北方人跟南方人这样这样这样。。 一边很复杂一边很有意思 ;)
      我也在学韩文~ 啊, 不过在上海还没找到交流语言的朋友 ;)

      (Yea, because China is so vast, there’s alot of different sub-cultures/society. I don’t think there’s just ONE China. You know some people say, “Oh people from Shanghai are like this, and BJese are like that, and people from North are this way, and Southerners are that..” It’s both complex and fascinating.

      Actually I’m studying Korean too, but I still haven’t found a Language Exchange partner in Shanghai.. ;) )

  2. 地图剪影上好像少了台湾省。
    大部分西方人和你想的可能不太一样,对社会主义有偏见。不过,我觉得你比美国之音的记者有良心多了。发自内心感谢你。^_^
    我可以把你的网站发给我所有的QQ好友,好不?祝网站越来越人气~

    天津市历史上曾有过“九国租界”,这边定居的韩国人也很多(5万左右)。有机会来天津玩啊~

    • 哦~ 对于台湾。。呵呵, 你说得没错, 我没想到啊 ;) 其实中国的地图太争论的吧呵呵。。哦呀,你最近学韩语啊?;) 我在上海,还没有找到韩国人交流语言~ 好可惜。。 不好意思,我没有QQ,不过有一天,我希望在天津见面呵呵!

  3. Pingback: What we learned this week « Make Wealth History

  4. Yeah, man.. When I was in postgrad, we talked about some of the options, and I always thought in terms of Economics (my geeky major).. and when suggesting things like population controls, or some variable taxation to either boost, or slow down population, a lot of people freaked out. But you know what? A chunk of the wealth we now see in China (don’t forget, its a developing country with huge income gap… long long way to go), is attributable to the population controls they put in about 30 years ago. Less people, higher GDP per Cap. Here we just have an unreal population. We need energy and we need food.

    Yeah, I didn’t think anyone was going to get HLJ (that’s HeiLongJiang, lit. ‘Black Dragon River’ a northern province) either. Hehe..I can use “SH” and pretty much any Chinese will get what it means (they even have the 1 <3 SH Tshirts, copying New York..sigh). But once you start shorthanding Su'zhou, and Shen'zhen, you start getting confused. ;)

  5. The problems in China are happening everywhere else in the world, but people tend to enjoy ignoring what is happening locally and focus on the outside. It’s the nature of bullying. They’re not happy with themselves, so choose to pick on someone else to make them feel better. China seems to be easy pickings when the government blocks a lot of internet access, so I’m not sure how aware the citizens are of the opinions the rest of the world holds on them. Whereas, if the United States media started picking on Canada, Canadians would hear about it instantly and react. The world could easily pick on Brazil and their deforestation of the Amazon, or even Canada and our oil sand pits, forestry and mining industries.

    Population restriction is a good idea if the birth rate is out of control. In Western nations, I believe I remember reading that the birth rate is dropping in comparison to previous decades. Of course, the baby boomers raised the rate to a ridiculous level. I’m not sure if the level we are at is sustainable or whether other policies should be in place.

    Unrelated, but it’s always interesting to see abbreviations from other countries. I would never rever to Shanghai as SH (I’m guessing that’s what it is, at least), and the only province I hear about is Tibet.

Discuss this Article

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s